Commercial Viability?
Commercial Viability?
Saturday, August 25, 2012 - 16:48
When creating a commercial project, arent all licenses but CC0 basically unusable?
The least restrictive, CC-BY 3.0 requires no use of any kind of DRM, which includes no packing of files or other limitations of access.
This seems to eliminate not only any meaningful Digital Distribution Platform out there, but also many game engines.
Am I understanding this correctly?
CC-BY has nothing to do with DRM. It should be easy to use CC-BY assets in a commercial game.
(edit)
Correction, there is a clause in CC-BY as well:
"You may not impose any effective technological measures on the Work that restrict the ability of a recipient of the Work from You to exercise the rights granted to that recipient under the terms of the License."
This clause makes a lot of sense for CC-BY-SA, but I'm not sure what it actually means for CC-BY.
I imagine a safe way to handle this is to include an extra non-DRM copy of all the CC-BY assets used with the distributable.
by-sa/3.0/legalcode (4(a))
I too consider this to have to do with DRM but I'm wondering if it's not enough if you add info on where to get the relevant in-game data DRM-free in the credits or something.
I think it's possible to not use DRM on Steam.
I think CC-By does indeed have some sorts of limits on DRM. But I don't know how extensive they are, or whether there are easy ways around them, which there may be. Generally, if you're having trouble with that you can just contact the artist who can give you individual permissions to override issues on that front.
To me, not having to contact the artist is a major benefit of freely licensed art: permissions are already clearly (EDIT: OK, maybe not so clear...) laid out.
True. But let's be honest: even our best licenses kinda suck sometimes ATM. Just look at all the confusion over what -By-SA means for licensing of other game assets.
Funny thing, I was just talking about how DRM is one of the reasons I stopped buying games. The last games I bought were DRM free humble indie bundle games that had free(as in speech) engines.
http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Commons:Licensing