Consistency with Style:
fits the guide well enough, mostly.
Quality and Skill:
Kind of ranges, the artist clearly has some talent and some are rather nice (the female elf) and some feel more lacking (the rogue)
Quantity:
there's a good number of things here
Judge's Opinion:
There's a good set of things here. The female elf and the longer female hair ones are the nicest contributions. A few things don't feel quite as nicely done: the rogue looks rather flat on shading, for example. That said, it's a nice contribution and the artist clearly invested herself in it, which is always good to see.
