Constructive criticism please?

Constructive criticism please?

felinoid's picture

I tried making some tilesets for a "game" I started writing (currently only consists of walking around). There's dirt, mudstone (which is what I've decided to call the generic gray stone), and peridotite (the green one). I mostly want to know how worried I should be about making the big blobs of the same type look better. They currently have 4 different variations of each sprite to try to avoid a visible grid, and have separate sprites for bordering air. The border tiles (the dirt ones are visible) are perhaps a tad bit rectangular, but I do want them to have corners where normal tiles would so that I don't have to make my collision detection fancier or have the player floating on air. Also I might want to eventually add dirt borders similar to the borders with air, for, say, two different types of rocks meeting. Please ignore the box pretending to be a player :).

Attachments: 
Preview
Screenshot - 01212017 - 05:20:40 PM.png Screenshot - 01212017 - 05:20:40 PM.png 394.6 Kb [9 download(s)]
Preview
Screenshot - 01242017 - 01:00:49 PM.png Screenshot - 01242017 - 01:00:49 PM.png 294.8 Kb [3 download(s)]