Unknowable. This isn't a user that has since been deleted. It was anon posting with no login back when that was (breifly) allowed here. But also, irrelevant. Whoever it was didn't require credit for their changes, so the only attribution required goes to Clint.
@Elbon Eastmage: As stated above, erotic content is not permitted on OGA. And, again as stated above, OP was not initially asking about erotic content. The original question was about NSFW content on OpenGameArt.org specifically... which is not the same thing as erotic content within video games in general. NSFW content is conditionally allowed on OGA, erotic content is not.
This thread is not the place to have a philosophical discussion about personal preferences for or against lewd/erotic game content.
No, just the assets it uses. What I mean is, your users are generating ships that fall under CC-BY-SA, but you are also using assets that fall under CC-BY-SA. Your users must adhere to the license if they use the ships created in your game, but so must you. That is all I meant. The license would not apply to your game itself, just those assets.
@ghawmzldjs71: Yes that would satisfy the license. Your game should also inlcude such attribution and license indications on it's credits page, but I assume you've already planned that, yes?
¿Puedo usar el arte que encuentro aquí? ¿Cómo debo acreditar al artista?
Sí, puede usar cualquiera de las obras de arte enviadas a este sitio. Incluso en proyectos comerciales. Solo asegúrese de cumplir con los términos de la licencia.
I have encountered some of that, but I may have had better luck shutting their lies down since the reason I rejected their art was not because it was AI art. It was because it didn't meet my commission criteria. In my case, I didn't care if it was AI or not so long as it created a stable animation loop that transitioned smoothly and realistically. The artwork they tried to give me and say "I finished the commission. pay up." looked like crap when it was animated. So I said, "no, you didn't finish. My requirements clearly say xyz and this doesn't meet that."
My point being, be sure to define your requirements in a way that excludes the garbage artifacts that often show up in AI art. Specifying "no AI art" might help a little, though I think you'll get more of the 'this is a witch hunt' responses for that. It isn't actually very specific. It's like saying "no blockchain!" but there are multiple forms of blockchain tech, many of which have nothing to do with the typical notorious "Steal art, mint NFT, sell it without artist's permission, argue the theft is actually beneficial to artist when caught" tactic.
@SilentAgony: See FAQ question #1: https://opengameart.org/content/faq#q-how-to-credit
Unknowable. This isn't a user that has since been deleted. It was anon posting with no login back when that was (breifly) allowed here.
But also, irrelevant. Whoever it was didn't require credit for their changes, so the only attribution required goes to Clint.
@Elbon Eastmage: As stated above, erotic content is not permitted on OGA. And, again as stated above, OP was not initially asking about erotic content. The original question was about NSFW content on OpenGameArt.org specifically... which is not the same thing as erotic content within video games in general. NSFW content is conditionally allowed on OGA, erotic content is not.
This thread is not the place to have a philosophical discussion about personal preferences for or against lewd/erotic game content.
No, just the assets it uses. What I mean is, your users are generating ships that fall under CC-BY-SA, but you are also using assets that fall under CC-BY-SA. Your users must adhere to the license if they use the ships created in your game, but so must you. That is all I meant. The license would not apply to your game itself, just those assets.
@ghawmzldjs71: Yes that would satisfy the license. Your game should also inlcude such attribution and license indications on it's credits page, but I assume you've already planned that, yes?
@GWalter343: Lea https://opengameart.org/content/faq#q-how-to-credit
Yes, clicking the play button previews the audio, but...
...You need to click on the title to open that asset's page.
From there, you can download it by clicking the file link under the word "File(s):"
Done
What does it being a toddler game have to do with linking to the game?
Agreed.
I have encountered some of that, but I may have had better luck shutting their lies down since the reason I rejected their art was not because it was AI art. It was because it didn't meet my commission criteria. In my case, I didn't care if it was AI or not so long as it created a stable animation loop that transitioned smoothly and realistically. The artwork they tried to give me and say "I finished the commission. pay up." looked like crap when it was animated. So I said, "no, you didn't finish. My requirements clearly say xyz and this doesn't meet that."
My point being, be sure to define your requirements in a way that excludes the garbage artifacts that often show up in AI art. Specifying "no AI art" might help a little, though I think you'll get more of the 'this is a witch hunt' responses for that. It isn't actually very specific. It's like saying "no blockchain!" but there are multiple forms of blockchain tech, many of which have nothing to do with the typical notorious "Steal art, mint NFT, sell it without artist's permission, argue the theft is actually beneficial to artist when caught" tactic.
Pages